Artisan Olive Oil Brands Worth Knowing

Founder Aishwarya Iyer started Brightland in 2018 after discovering how rampant fraud and rancidity were in the olive oil industry — she wanted to offer something genuinely traceable and fresh. Her approach was to market olive oil the way beauty brands market serums: with deliberate packaging, clear sourcing, and an emphasis on what the product actually does. All oils are California-grown, cold-pressed, and harvested at peak polyphenol density. The brand has expanded into infused oils, vinegars, and honey, but the EVOO remains the anchor.

Co-founders Andrew Benin and Allen Dushi launched Graza in 2022 with a simple insight: olive oil should be fun to use, and the squeeze bottle makes it actually drizzle-able in the kitchen. The oil is single-origin, made from Picual olives grown exclusively in Jaén, Spain — the world's largest olive oil producing region. The viral launch broke K in revenue before the brand had any ads running, driven entirely by the product's distinctiveness and a food-community influencer strategy that felt organic because it was.

Katina Mountanos founded Kosterina after buying what the label called 'Greek extra virgin olive oil' at a US supermarket and finding it tasted nothing like the oil her family produced in southern Greece. She sources exclusively from Koroneiki olives — a small, dense variety native to the Peloponnese — harvested early in the season when polyphenol levels peak and flavor is most intense. Kosterina has since expanded into skincare, leveraging the same high-antioxidant EVOO in facial formulations, which tracks with how Greeks have historically used olive oil.

Tucked into 150 acres of rolling hills in Paso Robles, California — wine country, not olive oil country, which is partly the point — Pasolivo grows 12 different olive varietals and mills them on site within hours of harvest. Hand-picking and same-day pressing are the kind of choices that cost more but make a measurable difference in oil quality. The result is a small-batch, estate-grown EVOO with a complexity that reads differently season to season, the way a good vintage does.

Brother and sister Effi and Tony Kasandrinos grew up with olive oil from their father's village in Greece — a product so central to family life that Kasandrinos babies are baptized with it. When they moved to the US and couldn't find anything that tasted right, they started importing from the family farm directly. The brand is a direct line from a multi-generational Greek grove to American kitchens, certified organic and cold-pressed with no intermediary.

McEvoy Ranch sits on 550 acres in the rolling hills of western Marin County, making it one of the largest estate-grown certified organic olive oil operations in the United States. The ranch presses multiple varietals — including Coratina, known for its high polyphenol content and herbaceous intensity — and labels each harvest year on the bottle. The 2024 Coratina Limited Edition, for instance, is noted for its green olive and dry grass character: the kind of tasting note that belongs in a wine shop, not a grocery aisle.

Frankies 457 Spuntino is the beloved Brooklyn restaurant started by Frank Castronovo and Frank Falcinelli — 'the Franks' — whose meticulous sourcing philosophy extends to their olive oil line. Their organic EVOO comes from the ASARO estate in Partanna, Sicily, made with Nocellara del Belice olives: the same variety used for Castelvetrano table olives, pressed here into an oil with a distinctively fruity, lightly peppery profile. It's the olive oil a serious cook recommends when asked.